BMW XM vs Mazda MX-5 Comparison

BMW XM

Mazda MX-5

How they stack

2025 BMW

2025 Mazda

MX-5

Select Variants...

How they stack...

CarExpert Rating

Very Good

Read the 2024 BMW XM Label Red review

This rating has been converted from our previous rating system. Read about our new review ratings.

Excellent

An outstanding car in almost every way. A joy to drive, packed with great features, and highly recommended.

Very Good

A well-rounded car that's enjoyable to drive, offers great value or features, and is easy to recommend.

Good

A solid choice that does most things well. Comfortable, capable, and worth considering in this segment.

Average

Meets the standard for this segment. May not stand out, but still a dependable and reasonable option.

Below Average

Falls a bit behind others in the segment, but still passes safety checks and may suit specific needs or budgets.

CarExpert Rating

Very Good

Read the 2024 Mazda MX-5 RF GT review

This rating has been converted from our previous rating system. Read about our new review ratings.

Excellent

An outstanding car in almost every way. A joy to drive, packed with great features, and highly recommended.

Very Good

A well-rounded car that's enjoyable to drive, offers great value or features, and is easy to recommend.

Good

A solid choice that does most things well. Comfortable, capable, and worth considering in this segment.

Average

Meets the standard for this segment. May not stand out, but still a dependable and reasonable option.

Below Average

Falls a bit behind others in the segment, but still passes safety checks and may suit specific needs or budgets.

Based on the BMW XM RED EDITION PHEV

Based on the Mazda MX-5 G20 RF GT BLK ROOF T/COTTA LTH

Best suitable for...

Fun

City driving

Fuel Efficiency

69L

186 km

45L

306 to 324 km

Warranty

5 year
warranty

MSRP

$302,200 - $349,900

$41,210 - $57,220

Save with CarExpert

CarExpert's Take

Alborz Fallah

Founder

Alborz Fallah drove this car and these were their findings:

Hits

Super interior fit and finish
Powertrain combination works a treat
Incredible presence anywhere it goes

Misses

Looks are not for all
Ride can be a little harsh
The most expensive BMW you can buy

Josh Nevett

Marketplace Journalist

Josh Nevett drove this car and these were their findings:

Hits

Fun to drive anywhere, anytime
RF brings coupe looks, flexibility
Compliant ride

Misses

Tan interior exclusive for auto
Limited passenger legroom
Steering lacks feedback

Reviews

2024 BMW XM Label Red review

The best of both worlds? The BMW XM is supercar-killing twin-turbo V8 monster masquerading as an electrified SUV.

Alborz Fallah

2024 Mazda MX-5 RF GT review

The Mazda MX-5 is the best selling roadster of all time, but it doesn't need a soft top or a manual transmission to make sense.

Josh Nevett

People Typically Compare to

Ready To Buy

FIND ME A DEAL

Gallery

30 Photos

Specs

Type
TURBO		PETROL DIRECT INJECTION
Size (cc)
4395		1998
Size (L)
4.4L		2.0L
Cylinders
8		4
Camshaft
DUAL OVERHEAD CAM		DUAL OVERHEAD CAM
Valves/Ports per Cylinder
32		16
Power
480kW - 550kW		135kW
Power RPM
-		7000
Torque
800Nm - 1000Nm		205Nm
Torque RPM
-		4000
Bore Stroke
-		91.2
Compression Ratio
-		-

Can’t Make Up Your Mind?

FOR FREE EXPERT ADVICE,

CALL US ON 1300 587 992

TALK TO AN EXPERT

News Topics

Best Cars

Guides

Popular Makes

BMW XM vs Mazda MX-5 Comparison

BMW XM

Mazda MX-5

How they stack...

CarExpert's Take

Reviews

People Typically Compare to

Ready To Buy

Gallery

Specs

Can’t Make Up Your Mind?

News Topics

Best Cars

Guides

Popular Makes

BMW XM vs Mazda MX-5 Comparison

BMW XM

Mazda MX-5

How they stack...

CarExpert's Take

Reviews

People Typically Compare to

Ready To Buy

Gallery

Specs

Engine

Transmission & Drivetrain

Fuel

Wheels & Tyres

Dimensions & Weights

Other

Safety

Can’t Make Up Your Mind?

Share This to a Friend